hey girlie your NOT picky im so much worse and i totaly understand that when it comes to anime, now FMA is one of the best anime i bought the whole series and the movie :] it's totally worth the buy if you love it alot
OuranHighSchool Host Club is another awsome one too i bought that lolz
now it's hard to find good voice over for english
but if your looking for an anime with sadness and funnyness lolz try Chrono Crusade.. i watched it in japanese so im not sure on the dub but you can look it up on wikipedia who dub's it and check to see if you like those voice acotrs from any other previous animes you watched :]
uhhh.. you might like Fruits basket its cutesy and nice but with a hint of darkness; the charecters will be nice for apart of the show but they can change in a second...also the fact that their a bi-polar charecter in that show lolz..its about the chinese zodiac and a family curse.. it entertaining to say teh least butttt..the main character has big eyes...except she's the only one with big eyes.....it's odd i just noticed that haha
alright it may seem a little out of your description but maybe try samurai champloo, it has strong family ties ..quick action scenes and it's really funny... it dates back to the fuedual era with ...well samurai derr..lolz it's a good watch i was surprised i liked it
you can also try ruroni kenshin but im not so sure about the dub since the show is kinda old but theres alot of romance in it when you really get into the series [50 eps in]
uhh.. again samurai's and yea but the art is pretty good
and the main character is like so easy to fall in love with lolz
if your looking for a funny anime try FLCL its hilarious and emotions are all twisted and tied between the characters its only 12 bittersweet episodes long but i couldn't stop watching :]
uhhh.. theres no English dub for the anime LOVELESS but if your into mild yaoi it's a good watch and an extremely emotion packed show ... it's art i personally love but you can try it out theres definitely brotherly love :P
OH! and try Peacemaker Kurogane it's definitly brotherly love in that anime and some action and LOTS of emotion it's not that long of a series about 26 episodes ... the main charecter ahs the voice of Wrath from Full Metal Alchemist and his older brothers voice is Edward Elric from Full Metal Alchemist :D trust me the voices are good except for one white haired charecter who's voice cracks, i dont know why they cast that crappy vocie acotr but luckily he isint a main charecter so you wont hear much of him :]
well if you need any more feel free to ask :D
PS: Most of the animes given above are shounen [boy oriented] gundam has robots hellsing is shounen most of those are action packed animes i think if you want more girly stuff take a look at the ones i posted...because i've seen all the ones they have posted and i would reccomend maybe 2 out of all of them if any