Deadliest Warrior: Joker vs. Riddler. You decide?

Question

Two arch rivals of Batman square off in a fight to the death. The simulation will be ran with 5 man squads including their leader.
Riddler's weapons:
Mid range: Crossword Puzzle throwing nets-Nets that lock onto victim for an easy kill.
Long range:TNT Jigsaw pieces-Explode on impact like a grenade but disguised.
Close range: Walking stick-Able to crack skulls if used correctly.

Joker's weapons:
Med range: Harpoon gun-Looks like a toy gun but when shot, impales victim.
Long range: Playing cards-Razor sharp, thrown with deadly accuracy like a shuriken
Close range:Switchblade-Signature weapon for the Joker, able to slice and dice.

My sypnosis
Net vs. Harpoon gun: The net can trap a victim and set up for a kill, but the Harpoon gun is very accurate and delivers a killing blow. Edge: Harpoon gun
Puzzle pieces vs. Playing cards: Puzzle pieces take a few seconds to detonate, and may not even dish out a killing blow, but the playing cards come in 52 and are sharp and deadly accurate. Edge: Playing cards
Walking stick vs. Switchblade: The switchblade is very sharp and concealable, but not very long. The walking stick and definitely impale the enemy and stun him for a few seconds. It is slow though. After a close call, I barely give the edge to the walking stick.

Who wins? I'd give the edge to the Joker because I would feel his men are better trained and his weapons are quick. The Riddler would put up a good fight, but his weapons seem to be more gimmicky than effective.

WHAT DO YOU THINK THOUGH?

Answer 1

Joker

Answer 2

Joker, Riddler is far too Cerebral to be a match for the Joker. He has none of the physical abilities he needs.



Joker, while not exactly physically oriented, does have combat skills. And of course if you're talking about the Heath Ledger Joker the riddler is so pwned.



Because that is the most combat effective joker I've ever seen.

Answer 3

I can't see this scenario happening. NO ONE takes on the Joker if they can help it, and Joker wouldn't waste time fighting Riddler.



If it DID happen, big if, Joker would easily win. Eddie isn't about fighting, his gadgets are meant to distract, not kill.

Answer 4

Joker he's much more Crazier, Never mess with crazzy people.



the Riddler would just try to use his creative mind and take too long.

Answer 5

I say the Joker but Ra's Al Ghul is my favorite villain because he is master of martial arts and trained Batman.